Advertisement

In-N-Out design fight heads to City Council as opposition, supporters mobilize

The council will review the Architectural Review Committee’s reluctant approval of the restaurant’s design, with opponents organizing and fans rallying behind the burger chain on social media.

The building that housed a Bank of America location in the Smoke Tree Village shopping plaza has been torn down. Developers hope to put an In-N-Out in its place.

The months-long battle over whether In-N-Out Burger’s signature design belongs in Palm Springs is headed to the City Council on Monday (Nov. 23), giving elected officials a chance to weigh in on a project that has divided architectural reviewers and stirred passionate reactions among residents.

The council will hold a public hearing to reconsider the Architectural Review Committee’s 3-2 approval of the proposed restaurant at Smoke Tree Village, where the California burger chain hopes to build a 3,886-square-foot restaurant with a drive-thru at the former Bank of America site.

Local reporting and journalism you can count on.

Subscribe to The Palm Springs Post

The review comes after a councilmember requested that the project be brought before the full council, a procedure allowed under city rules. The council can uphold the committee’s decision, change the conditions attached to its approval or overturn it entirely.

The debate has also spilled beyond City Hall. Opposition has formed among residents who object to the restaurant’s design and have voiced their opposition to it, while a contingent of In-N-Out fans has taken to social media to voice enthusiastic support for bringing the popular burger chain to Palm Springs.

At issue, however, is not whether In-N-Out can operate at the location, but what the restaurant should look like.

The Planning Commission approved the restaurant and its drive-thru in July 2025, leaving the ARC to evaluate the building’s appearance and landscaping. That earlier approval is final, meaning the council’s review Monday will be limited to architectural issues rather than traffic, circulation or land use.

Those architectural details have proven particularly contentious.

Advertisement

When In-N-Out returned to the committee Oct. 19, its latest renderings showed several concessions to Palm Springs’ design standards. The chain had replaced its signature thick red trim with aluminum silver, flattened the roofline and removed glass blocks from the windows.

But committee members remained dissatisfied with the bright white building and its overall appearance, describing the design as a “sore thumb,” something that would “stand out, but not in a good way,” and a project that belonged in San Dimas rather than Palm Springs.

Planning Commissioner David Murphy, speaking as a member of the public, called the design “a Frankenstein monster designed by opposing committees.”

Despite those objections, the committee voted 3-2 to approve the project, but only on the condition that In-N-Out address outstanding design requirements. Those include squaring off building corners, simplifying the trash enclosure, adding shade trees and improving landscaping to screen the drive-thru.

The vote reflected the committee’s limited options under city rules restricting the number of public hearings for development projects. As the meeting concluded, one member was heard sighing into a microphone, “Well, nobody won.”

Advertisement

Monday’s hearing gives the council broader authority to revisit that decision. According to the staff report, councilmembers may affirm the approval as written, modify its conditions or deny the architectural application.

A denial would require In-N-Out to submit a new architectural review application if it wants to proceed. The restaurant’s underlying development approval, however, would remain valid until Jan. 8, 2028, unless extended.

The stakes extend beyond one building. Supporters have argued that the restaurant would help revitalize Smoke Tree Village, while critics maintain that even a nationally recognized brand should meet Palm Springs’ architectural expectations.


Author

Mark is the founder and publisher of The Post. He first moved to the Coachella Valley in 1994 and is currently a Palm Springs resident. After a long career in newspapers (including The Desert Sun) and major news websites such as ESPN.com and MSN.com, he started The Post in 2021.

Sign up for news updates.

Close the CTA

Receive vital news about our city in your inbox for free every day.

100% local.

Close the CTA

The Post was founded by local residents who saw gaps in existing news coverage and believed our community deserved better.